Why Hermès and Aldi are opening stores while Gucci and Carrefour are closing them

03 November 2026 Consultancy.eu 8 min. read

Store expansion is no longer a question of how many locations a retailer can open, but whether sufficient demand already exists to make each one viable. Experts from Istanbul-based consultancy Mondial & Co explore how this shift is reshaping the luxury and grocery sectors, with lessons from Hermès, Aldi, Lidl, Kering and Carrefour on when to expand, consolidate or rethink a retail network.

Luxury houses and grocery chains sit at opposite ends of retail, yet the same rule now decides which of them open stores and which close them. Hermès and the discounters Aldi and Lidl open stores to serve demand that already exists, with a narrow offer they control and customers who return. Kering and Carrefour built large networks to create demand during the boom years, and both are now closing stores and retreating to their strongest markets.

Luxury entered 2026 after its first sustained contraction in fifteen years. The personal luxury goods market declined by about 2% to €358 billion in 2025, and the global base of luxury consumers fell from roughly 400 million in 2022 to around 330 million, according to research from Bain & Company and Altagamma.

Kering, the Paris group behind Gucci, Saint Laurent and Bottega Veneta, closed a net 75 stores in 2025 and a further 84 in the first half of 2026, while Hermès grew revenue by 6.1% at constant exchange rates to €8.16 billion and opened or enlarged stores from Hanoi and Beijing to London and Berlin.

Grocery shows the same divergence. Carrefour, the group that took the hypermarket around the world, now concentrates its growth on France, Spain and Brazil and is selling businesses elsewhere, while Aldi Nord opened 100 new stores last year and Action added 384.

Read side by side, the two sectors describe one shift in how consumers buy, and the closures in each make more sense once that shift is clear.

Two ways to open a store

A store can be opened to create demand or to serve it. In the first model, the store is a marketing investment that brings the brand to a new street or a new city, attracts traffic and converts visitors into first time buyers. In the second, the store follows customers who already exist, who already know what they want and who come back regularly.

Both models work while a market expands. When it contracts, the first model loses its traffic and its economics, while the second barely registers the change.

The boom years in luxury and the global expansion of the hypermarket both followed the first model. Luxury houses opened boutiques to meet a fast-growing aspirational clientele in China, the Gulf and the large tourist cities, and Carrefour opened vast stores in emerging markets to create a new shopping habit. Both are now unwinding networks built for consumers who have changed.

A store of Gucci in Paris, France

Hermès and the discounters grow on a narrow, controlled offer

Hermès and the discounters look unrelated, yet their models share the same structure. Hermès makes its own products in its own workshops, opening its 25th leather workshop in April 2026, and demand for its leading leather goods consistently exceeds what it can produce, so each boutique serves clients who are already waiting.

Aldi and Lidl sell a deliberately narrow range built mostly on their own brands, which gives them the same control over product and price and brings the same households back several times a week.

Both expand by following customers who already exist. Hermès opens and enlarges stores where it has established local clienteles, and its executive chairman has said the house prefers to sell to clients in their home country more than to tourists. The discounters open close to where households already shop: Aldi added 100 stores in 2025 in and plans 40 more in 2026, while Lidl is opening 40 stores in Spain alone this year. Action, meanwhile, grew its 2025 sales by 16% to €16 billion.

In each case a new store starts with demand already in place, which is why it pays back quickly.

Kering and Carrefour are unwinding networks built for a boom

Kering and Carrefour are following almost the same playbook. Kering plans at least 100 net closures in 2026, another 100 across 2027 and 2028, and a network at least 250 stores smaller by 2030, roughly half of it at Gucci, whose revenue fell 22% to €5.99 billion in 2025. McQueen will operate with about half the stores it had at the end of 2025, and Gucci has been closing stores in China, including its Wuhan location in May 2026.

Carrefour sold control of its Chinese business in 2019 after shoppers moved online and its hypermarkets lost relevance, has since left Italy, agreed the sale of its Romanian business and announced reviews of Belgium, Poland and Argentina.

Both groups are also selling assets to refocus on their core. Kering sold Kering Beauté to L’Oréal in a deal worth about €4 billion, and Carrefour’s Romanian business was valued at €823 million. In April 2026 Carrefour announced the sale of its remaining stake in Carrefour in Türkiye, ending its presence in the country.

The figure that explains the logic comes from Kering. Management has said the group keeps between 30% and 80% of a closed store’s sales when clients and staff move to a nearby location, because loyal clients follow the associate and the brand. The same holds in grocery, where a household’s weekly basket moves to the nearest discounter or the next supermarket, which means the extra store mainly added cost. In the first half of 2026 Kering returned to comparable growth of 1% while closing 84 stores.

Carrefour is one of the world’s largest supermarket groups

New owners reset the offer before adding stores

A third group in both sectors has chosen to fix the proposition first. Prada Group, which acquired Versace while it was operating at a loss, has announced further Versace store closures in 2026 and 2027, with new openings planned from 2028 once the creative reset has rebuilt demand.

In the Gulf, Majid Al Futtaim, which holds the Carrefour franchise in the region, kept the stores in Kuwait, Bahrain, Oman and Jordan but replaced the Carrefour brand with its own HyperMax banner. In both cases the owner decided that the existing proposition no longer earned the customer’s visit and changed it before committing more capital to stores.

The same consumer stands behind both trends

The aspirational luxury buyer and the hypermarket shopper are often the same household, and the same change has reached both decisions. That consumer now arrives with the purchase already decided, having researched, compared and often ordered online before reaching any store, and spends with sharper judgement on both value and distinction.

This answers whether the closures are about profit or about a changed consumer. The consumer changed first, and that change removed the economic case for stores whose job was to persuade, whether a Gucci boutique on a secondary street or a hypermarket on the edge of town. The closures are the financial consequence. Stores whose job is to serve a customer who has already decided, whether by allocating a scarce bag or supplying the weekly basket nearby, remain profitable and keep opening.

The strategic go-to-market

At Mondial & Co, we observe that leading brands follow the demand-led model. They test demand through online sales, marketplace partners, private appointments, wholesale or private label partnerships before signing a lease, choose the partner and the address once the customers are visible, and treat the store as the reward for demand already earned.

They follow a tried-and-tested approach, asking four simple questions before deciding whether to open or close a store:

1) Does demand already exist?
Online orders, marketplace sales, client lists, distributor data and partner sell through should show a decided customer base before a lease is signed.

2) Is this store creating demand or serving it?
A store whose main purpose is visibility or traffic capture deserves review first, since its economics depend on a market that keeps expanding.

3) How much revenue will follow the customer?
Kering’s experience in luxury and the behaviour of grocery shoppers both show that a large share of sales moves to a nearby store, which changes the case for consolidation.

4) Does the company control its offer?
Hermès through its workshops and the discounters through their own brands decide what they sell and at what price, which lets each store run on predictable demand.

The key takeaway

Taken together, the two sectors point to a single discipline. Hermès keeps the supply of its most wanted bags below the number of clients who want one, and Aldi keeps its range at a fraction of what a hypermarket stocks, so both ration choice, and every store they open meets demand that already exceeds what it offers. Gucci and Carrefour grew the other way, adding doors, collections and aisles faster than customers arrived, and the closures now under way correct that surplus.

The retailers opening stores in 2026 are those whose supply of doors, products and range runs slightly behind demand, and the retailers closing them are those whose supply ran ahead.