Sia benchmark: Digital divide emerges among Western European mortgage providers
Mortgage providers across Western Europe are increasingly moving towards a digital customer experience. Yet progress remains uneven, with providers in the Netherlands and Belgium leading the digital race. That is according to the Mortgage Credit Benchmark 2026 from Sia.
The study by Sia examined the end-to-end digital journey of a new mortgage prospect across 68 mortgage providers in nine Western European countries: the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, France, Italy, Spain, the United Kingdom, Ireland and Germany.
The researchers found that many providers still have a long way to go. In the early stages of the customer journey, such as researching options and running calculations – for example, comparing interest rates and calculating maximum borrowing capacity and monthly payments – mortgage providers are generally well equipped digitally. Further along the journey, however, the differences between providers become much more pronounced.
The average score across all mortgage providers was 35.2%. The best-performing players, classified as ‘Digital Leaders’, scored as high as 64.8%, while the lowest-performing providers, classified as ‘Laggards’, scored just 10.1%. The results indicate that significant progress is still needed to fully digitalise the mortgage process for clients.
HSBC claimed the top spot in Sia’s benchmark, followed by five other providers that also ranked in the Digital Leaders segment: BoursoBank (France), Centraal Beheer (Netherlands), KBC (Belgium), Allianz NL (Netherlands) and Keytrade (Belgium).
Where the gap really opens up
The benchmark scores providers across five equally weighted phases: information and simulation, the online application form, the online proposal, the pre-agreement and binding credit offer, and the overall user experience. AI and ESG are assessed across all five phases.
Etienne Ranwez, Managing Director at Sia, said that providers tend to converge at the start of the journey, with most offering a broadly comparable calculator and rate-comparison experience, regardless of their overall digital maturity.
“The real divide opens at the pre-agreement and binding-offer stage, where Digital Leaders complete the process end to end online, while Followers and Laggards still route the client back to an advisor or branch for the binding offer and signature.”
That single phase, more than any other, separates a Digital Leader from a Digital Follower.
Time to act
Ranwez says all players in the market need to focus on their opportunities for improvement, particularly as the digital customer journey is set to become increasingly important to success in the market. At the same time, customer expectations are rising as AI becomes more widespread.
Homebuyers are also increasingly expecting an ecosystem approach, in which mortgage providers work together with a range of partners, such as estate agents, surveyors, notaries and sustainability partners. This creates a customer journey that saves time while making the process more seamless, transparent and convenient.
“The customer journey doesn’t begin at the application and doesn’t end at the signature,” said Ranwez. “The winners recognise a client’s need before the client even calls, build a network of partners around the client’s project, and let them manage everything themselves once the mortgage is signed. Digitalisation doesn’t replace advice, it sharpens it, because you understand the client’s situation far better.”
The report identifies four trends that will shape the market over the coming years: proactive engagement, where providers surface relevant guidance before a prospect even applies; seamless digital journeys that combine self-service with human advice at the moments that matter; digital self-service after completion, as clients increasingly expect to manage their mortgage, overpayments and amendments themselves; and ecosystem partnerships, where leading providers connect estate agents, surveyors, notaries and sustainability partners around the client’s project rather than asking the client to coordinate each one separately.
Sia in financial services
Headquartered in Europe, Sia is a global management consulting group with more than 3,000 professionals across 19 countries. In the financial services sector, the firm advises institutions on strategy, digital transformation, compliance and customer experience.

